China’s ivory trade ban: workshop held on the achievement and challenges
Beijing, China, 29 January 2018—China’s ivory trade ban was hailed as “a milestone in wildlife conservation worldwide” at a major international workshop co-hosted by WWF, TRAFFIC and the China Wildlife Conservation Association in Beijing today.
The workshop was attended by 120 people, including representatives from China’s State Forestry Administration, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora Management Authority (CITES MA), Foreign Ministry, enforcement agencies including China Customs and Forestry Police, the ivory carving industry, academia and businesses, WWF, TRAFFIC, and major NGOs operating in China.
On 31 December 2017, China, where ivory carving has been important to national culture for over 2000 years, kept its promise and closed its legal ivory market. The move has been widely praised as potentially a game changer that might help to reverse the decline of wild African Elephant populations. According to a recent rapid market visit, all registered ivory sale and processing sites had ceased their processing and sale of ivory and ivory products by the timetabled deadline indicating that the ivory ban is on track.
At the one-day workshop, WWF and TRAFFIC presented key findings of major research conducted last year. TRAFFIC’s report: Revisiting China’s Ivory Markets in 2017 shows the number of ivory items offered for sale—in both legal and illegal ivory markets in China has declined alongside falling ivory prices after the announcement of timetable of the ban. Further to this, a Globescan survey commissioned by WWF and TRAFFIC: Demand under the Ban: China ivory consumption research 2017, examined ivory consumers’ attitudes in the context of the ban. Research found the ban has widespread public support and is likely to reduce consumers' ivory buying substantially, although public awareness is very low. Ivory purchases have dropped in many cities surveyed where regulations might be stricter and there is more awareness about the ivory trade ban, especially in Beijing and Chengdu, but ivory buying has been moving from these major cities to regional cities in China over the past three years.
“China has demonstrated great political will and commitment on this issue given the deep importance ivory has played in Chinese tradition and culture and its status in the region. We hope that other countries in East and Southeast Asia urgently follow suit and legislate and enforce their own bans to help prevent ivory moving illegally from China into their domestic markets.” Margaret Kinnaird, WWF Wildlife Practice Leader said. “Today’s workshop gave us a chance to discuss the next steps with key actors both in China and its immediate neighbours where legal ivory markets persists or existing bans are not strictly enforced.”
Several panel discussions were held on law enforcement, demand reduction, inheritance of ivory carving and the role of NGOs in supporting China’s ivory trade ban. While recognizing the achievement of the Chinese ban, delegates identified strengthening law enforcement capacity to combat illegal trade, especially that which occurs through social media channels, and reduce market demand as the key challenges for effective implementation of the ban in the future. And they highlighted the need to increase the awareness of tourists that bringing ivory back into China is also illegal.
“An assessment of what it takes effectively to change consumer behaviour has highlighted the efficacy of a twin-track approach to ensure sustained success: adequately enforced policy change underpinned by targeted consumer outreach,” said Lo Sze Ping, Chief Representative of WWF China.
“Recognizing the magnitude of the challenge, WWF will continue to work with partners to change consumer behaviour to reduce consumption of ivory in China and other relevant Asian markets.”
At the workshop, local ivory industry representatives recognized that ivory carving is regarded as China’s intangible cultural heritage and argued that the ivory ban is a sacrifice China has made for the sake of the survival of African Elephants. They highlighted the need to carry-forward ivory carving skills in a non-commercial way.
TRAFFIC and WWF are fully committed to providing evidence-based support to the government’s implementation of the ban through market monitoring and research. We have already scaled up our public engagement efforts and developed tailored messaging based on our research findings to influence different consumer groups
Zhou Fei, Head of TRAFFIC’s China office and WWF’s China Wildlife Trade ProgrammeThe Beijing workshop is part of a series of workshops WWF and TRAFFIC have been hosting in China to promote and support the ivory trade ban, the first of them held in Beijing in 2015, and subsequent ones in Xishuanbanna in March 2016 and Chengdu in October 2016.